[ Pdf God's Playground: A History of Poland, Vol. 1 è african-american PDF ] by Norman Davies ✓ pamyatnik.pro
[ Pdf God's Playground: A History of Poland, Vol. 1 è african-american PDF ] by Norman Davies ✓ Norman Davies is an outstanding historian who is one of the world s leading experts in Polish history, and the book demonstrates this It contains a wealth of detail that paints the daily life in historic times, but also analyses long term developments within the Polish nation as well as in international politics, of which Poland has so often and so dramatically been the victim This is simply the best and most comprehensive book on Polish history written by a non Pole.
There were however also a few things I did not like about the book The first is that Davies tends often to assume that you are already familiar with the main events When he introduces a subject he will often already then link it up with future events, like certain risings or battles, that at that point will not have been discussed He can also get quite academic in some parts and bother you with lots o I wanted to rate this higher Davies produced a masterful study of Poland s pre partition history, but it may be the densest tome I ve ever picked up Imagine a book with a full chapter devoted to the Vistula grain trade Yet I stuck with it, and read every last page, even thought the going was slow Davies is a serious scholar who has dug into primary source material to produce a thorough, masterful study of Poland, and reading it gives one a sense of the polish national mindset.
An incredible book, even if I can t remember ever taking so long to finish one Extremely dense with information there s than a person could ever hope to retain to memory here fact after fact What really makes this book stand out in my mind though is that Davies makes it all come together I may not remember many of the dates and details, but I feel like I have a general understanding of Polish history that I never obtained from any other text on the subject Davies also doesn t shy away from argument, he takes conventional myths on head on with historical fact Zbit dobra.
Ahh I ve actually made this my last book of the year God s Playground has been sitting on my bookshelf for years I can t believe that I waited so long to read it It was a long and dense read, but this book gives its reader a view of history of Poland though with a focus on the commonwealth great detail which I haven t really seen in a history book before and for that reason, I love it.
This Davies book is comparable to historic novel than to the serious historian work a almost no original historic sources aka chronicles and documents were used actually this book is a compilation of historic works from other authors b strange priorities sometimes a significant event e.
g Thirteen Years War is almost neglected by Davies only short paragraph was dedicated , but Davies indulges in inserting long letters and descriptions of minor things and events good example lengthy narration about a brawl of drunken Szlachta c he even makes factual errors Grand Duke Witold ruled Grand Duchy of Lithuania from 1392 not from 1401 according to Davies in 1401 Witold was granted just wider autonomy according to the Pact of Vilnius and Radom d some phrases in Latin and French are
The History of Poland as written by Norman Davies I found Vol 1 to be a bit of a slog to read, especially the middle which described in great detail the foundation of the Republic, and the religious and nobility structure of it However, it does cover the timeline of Polish dynasties and with masterful description of the Kings, the union with Lithuania and the Republic, as well as the foreign web of complexities involving the Kings following the Jagiellonians, culminating in the events leading to the complete Partition of Poland, and it ceasing to exist as a separate entity.
I am not sure if I got a full answer, but the book definitely helped in clarifying the main reason why I seeked it to begin with i.
e why is the history of the Polish rulers so complicated, and their selection always involving some form of